REMAKES vs ORIGINALS: The Hollywood War That’s Destroying Cinema (Or Saving It

-

**BREAKING**: Hollywood just announced 47 reboots, remakes, and sequels for next year. Meanwhile, original films are fighting for scraps at the box office. Is this the death of creativity, or the evolution of storytelling?


The battle lines are drawn. In one corner: **Team Original** - filmmakers screaming for fresh stories, new voices, untold tales. In the other corner: **Team Remake** - studios banking on proven formulas, nostalgic audiences, and billion-dollar franchises.


**Who’s winning? Who’s right? And why should you care?**


Grab some popcorn. This cinematic war is about to get messy.


## 🥊 ROUND 1: The Remake Invasion


**The Facts Are Brutal:**


- 2024: 8 of the top 10 movies were sequels, reboots, or franchise films

- Original films struggled to crack $100 million globally

- Studios greenlit 3 remakes for every 1 original screenplay

- **Barbie** (based on a toy) made $1.4 billion

- **Oppenheimer** (original biographical drama) made $950 million


**Wait… that last one breaks the pattern.**


**The Remake Strategy**: Why risk $200 million on an unknown story when you can remake **The Lion King** and guarantee a billion-dollar payday? Audiences already love these characters, these worlds, these songs. It’s basically printing money.


**Recent Remake Wins:**


- **Top Gun: Maverick** - 36 years later, still flying high

- **Dune** - Turned a “unfilmable” book into a blockbuster franchise

- **The Batman** - Proved you can reinvent the same character for the 50th time

- **Spider-Man: No Way Home** - Made fans cry by bringing back THREE different Spider-Men


**The argument**: These aren’t lazy cash grabs. They’re **evolution**. Better technology, deeper themes, updated perspectives on classic stories.


## ⚡ ROUND 2: The Original Resistance Fights Back


**But wait!** Before you surrender to remake supremacy, consider this: **some of 2024’s biggest surprises were totally original**.


**Original Film Victories:**


- **Everything Everywhere All at Once** - Weird, wonderful, and won Best Picture

- **Nope** - Jordan Peele’s original UFO thriller

- **The Menu** - A twisted culinary horror that no one saw coming

- **Glass Onion** - Rian Johnson’s original murder mystery (yes, it’s a sequel, but totally standalone)


**The Original Argument**: Remakes are **creative cowardice**. Instead of taking risks, studios are just reheating yesterday’s dinner. Where are the groundbreaking stories? The fresh voices? The films that will define THIS generation instead of recycling the last one?


**What We’re Losing:**


- **Cultural diversity** - Most remakes are of Western, white-dominated properties

- **Artistic risk-taking** - Why experiment when you can follow a proven formula?

- **New stars** - Remakes often rely on established names instead of discovering talent

- **Generational identity** - Are we creating anything uniquely ours?


## 🎬 ROUND 3: The Plot Twist Nobody Saw Coming


**Here’s where it gets interesting**: What if the remake vs. original debate is missing the point entirely?


**Case Study: Barbie vs. Oppenheimer**


**Barbie** was technically a “remake” (based on existing IP), but Greta Gerwig used it to deliver **completely original** commentary on feminism, capitalism, and identity. It wasn’t lazy - it was **subversive**.


**Oppenheimer** was “original” but told a **true story** everyone already knew. Christopher Nolan didn’t invent the atomic bomb - he just found a new way to show it.


**The Mind-Bending Truth**: The best films transcend the original/remake divide. They’re about **execution, vision, and purpose** - not source material.


## 🔥 ROUND 4: Why Audiences Are Actually Genius


**Plot twist**: Maybe audiences aren’t mindless franchise zombies. Maybe they’re smarter than we think.


**The Evidence:**


- **The Marvels** (franchise film) - Bombed spectacularly

- **Indiana Jones 5** (beloved franchise) - Massive disappointment

- **The Flash** (superhero remake/reboot) - Studio disaster

- Meanwhile, **M3GAN** (original horror) was a surprise hit


**What audiences actually want**: **Good stories well told**. They don’t care if it’s original or remake - they care if it’s **engaging, emotional, and entertaining**.


**The Real Pattern**: When remakes fail, it’s not because they’re remakes. It’s because they’re **bad remakes**. When originals fail, it’s not because they’re original. It’s because they’re **bad originals**.


## 💥 ROUND 5: The International Game-Changer


**Here’s what American critics miss**: The global box office is **rewriting all the rules**.


**Examples:**


- **RRR** (original Indian epic) - Became a worldwide phenomenon

- **Parasite** (original Korean thriller) - Won Best Picture

- **Everything Everywhere All at Once** (original sci-fi comedy) - Swept the Oscars


**The New Reality**: International audiences are hungry for **fresh perspectives**, even when they’re completely original. Streaming has made global distribution easier than ever.


**What this means**: Studios can’t just rely on American nostalgia anymore. They need stories that work everywhere - and sometimes that means **going completely original**.


## 🎯 THE VERDICT: Who Really Wins?


**After 5 brutal rounds, here’s the shocking truth**:


**BOTH SIDES ARE RIGHT. AND BOTH SIDES ARE WRONG.**


**Remakes win when they**:


- Use familiar foundations to explore new themes

- Update outdated perspectives for modern audiences

- Bring superior technology to great stories

- **Example: Dune, The Batman, Top Gun: Maverick**


**Remakes fail when they**:


- Copy without adding anything new

- Rely on nostalgia instead of quality

- Ignore what made the original special

- **Example: Mulan (2020), The Lion King (2019), most horror remakes**


**Originals win when they**:


- Take genuine creative risks

- Offer fresh perspectives on universal themes

- Create new worlds and characters we fall in love with

- **Example: Everything Everywhere, Parasite, Get Out**


**Originals fail when they**:


- Prioritize weirdness over story

- Assume audiences want “difficult” art

- Forget that entertainment matters too

- **Example: Too many indie films to list**


## 🚀 THE FUTURE: What Happens Next?


**Prediction**: The remake vs. original war will end when we realize it was never the right question.


**The right question**: Is this film **worth your time and money**, regardless of where the story comes from?


**What’s coming**:


- **AI will generate infinite remakes** - making human creativity more valuable

- **Global streaming will reward originality** - because every culture wants to see themselves

- **Audiences will get pickier** - because they have infinite options

- **The best filmmakers will use both strategies** - original stories in familiar formats, fresh takes on classic tales


## ⚡ YOUR MISSION: Choose Your Fighter


**Team Remake**: Support films that **elevate** existing properties. Demand quality, not just familiarity.


**Team Original**: Seek out fresh voices and new stories. Make them profitable so studios keep making them.


**Team Smart Audience**: Judge every film on its own merits. Great stories come from everywhere.


**The Ultimate Truth**: Cinema survives when **passionate filmmakers** tell **compelling stories** - whether they’re completely original or creatively remade.


**What matters isn’t the source. What matters is the vision.**


-----


**🎬 WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON?**

Are you Team Original, Team Remake, or Team “Just Make Good Movies”? Drop a comment with your favorite remake that improved on the original, and your favorite original film that took real creative risks.


**🔥 SHARE THIS** if you think the remake vs. original debate is missing the real point about what makes cinema great.


**Next week**: We’re diving into the most controversial remakes ever made - and why some of them are actually better than the originals. (Yes, we’re going there.)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When Billionaires Become Blood Sport *How The White Lotus and Succession turned wealth-watching into America’s favorite spectacle

-
Image
  There’s a moment in * Succession * where Roman Roy casually mentions spending more on a watch than most people make in a year. He says it like he’s talking about lunch. Meanwhile, in * The White Lotus *, a tech bro demands the hotel staff move a tree because it’s blocking his Instagram shot. Both moments land like gut punches—not because they’re unbelievable, but because they’re so painfully believable. Welcome to the golden age of “rich people are trash” television, where HBO has turned the moral bankruptcy of the ultra-wealthy into appointment viewing. *Succession* and *The White Lotus* aren’t just shows about money—they’re cultural autopsies of a society that’s finally ready to watch its elites get what they deserve. ## Two Flavors of Toxic Wealth These shows serve up different courses in the same feast of schadenfreude : **Succession** gives us *institutional* wealth—the Roy family empire built on media manipulation and political puppeteering. This is old money with new cr...
Read more

Beyond the Runway: Why The Devil Wears Prada Still Defines Power and Image in 2025

-
Image
  When *The Devil Wears Prada* premiered in 2006, audiences thought they were getting a fashion comedy with Meryl Streep playing dress-up as a demanding boss. Instead, they got something far more subversive: a razor-sharp dissection of power, ambition, and the price of success that feels more relevant today than ever before. As news breaks of a sequel filming in New York , it’s worth examining why this story about magazines and makeovers became one of the most enduring workplace narratives of the 21st century. The answer lies not in its glossy surface, but in its unflinching look at systems of power that extend far beyond the fashion world. ## The Soft-Spoken Revolution of Miranda Priestly Meryl Streep’s Miranda Priestly didn’t just create a character—she birthed an archetype that redefined how we understand female authority . Inspired by Vogue ’s Anna Wintour , Miranda could have been another shrieking caricature of a female boss. Instead, Streep delivered something far more chil...
Read more

Welcome to Beyond The Screen

-
Image
The world doesn’t end when you close your laptop. It doesn’t pause when you put down your phone. And the most powerful stories aren’t always the ones flickering on our displays. That’s what this space is here to explore. We live in an age where screens dominate our attention—where Netflix queues replace evening walks, where Instagram stories substitute for real conversations, where we’ve somehow convinced ourselves that life happens in pixels and notifications. But what if we’ve got it backwards? What if the most compelling narratives are the ones unfolding right outside our field of vision? Beyond the Screen is about reclaiming those stories. It’s about the filmmaker who finds inspiration in a stranger’s gesture on the subway. The writer who discovers their next character while eavesdropping at a coffee shop. The artist who realizes that the most authentic human moments can’t be captured in a frame—they have to be lived. Here, we’ll dive into the intersection where digital creativi...
Read more